Trouble with images? View as a Web page.

 
Polsinelli - Financial and Fiduciary Litigation
         

  

April 2014

  

Moving a Trust to Delaware? Follow the Trail of Peierls

  

 
 

  

     

  

 
 

Financial and Fiduciary Litigation Leaders:

  

Robert A. Henderson

Practice Area Chair

816.374.0530

rhenderson@polsinelli.com

 

John M. Kilroy, Jr.

Practice Area Vice Chair

816.374.0584

jkilroyjr@polsinelli.com

  

  

To view a full list of our Financial and Fiduciary Professionals, click here.

  

To learn more about our Financial and Fiduciary practice, or to contact one of our attorneys, click here.

  


View Polsinelli documents on JD Supra  
LinkedIn Twitter Facebook Inside Law Podcast Connect with us on LinkedIn. Connection with us on Twitter. Connect with us on Facebook.

 

   

Delaware has a rich history of providing guidance and innovation in corporate law and trust matters and to that end has become a jurisdiction of choice for the creation and migration of trusts. Recently, Delaware's Court of Chancery and Supreme Court each issued a set of three landmark opinions, the Peierls family trust cases, significantly affecting Delaware trust law and providing substantial guidance for those considering the placement of trusts in that state.

Traditionally, the preferred method to migrate trusts to Delaware has been filing consent petitions in the Court of Chancery. In Peierls, that Court denied the "routine" relief regularly requested through consent petitions, causing many to believe an end was near to Delaware's status as a trust destination of choice. However, though the Delaware Supreme Court affirmed much of the Court of Chancery's holdings, its opinions made clear that Delaware will remain an advantageous and preferred destination to transfer trusts. Through these opinions, Delaware's Courts expounded on important issues germane to transferring trusts between jurisdictions while also eliminating much of the uncertainty of the consent petition process.

Importantly, the Delaware Supreme Court clarified the application of conflicts of laws when transferring trusts from one jurisdiction to another—an area with little prior guidance. The opinions explained: (1) how to determine which state's law controls the administration of a trust; (2) which court had jurisdiction over a trust; and (3) which law governs judicial modification. Some of the "routine" relief previously sought in these consent petitions was eliminated; an example of which being the Court's acceptance of jurisdiction over the incoming trust and approving trustee resignations and successor trustee appointments. But the Supreme Court provided clear guidelines concerning what relief is available. The Supreme Court's opinions reflect how the Chancery Court will apply conflicts of laws going forward and when Delaware law governs a trust's administration. In summary, the Delaware Supreme Court held:

Trust Provisions for Change of Situs and Governing Law for Administration

Delaware law will govern if

  • a Delaware trustee is appointed;
  • if the trust's administrative provisions allows for the appointment of a successor trustee without geographic limitations on the trustee's location; or
  • if there is no choice of law provision explicitly stating another jurisdiction's laws must control the trust's administration in perpetuity.

When Delaware Courts Have Jurisdiction Over a Trust's Administrative Matters

The Court of Chancery has jurisdiction to hear trust administration issues when it possesses jurisdiction over all parties, including trustees. But when another court has reserved "primary jurisdiction" over a trust, then the Court of Chancery will yield to the court of "primary jurisdiction" and not exercise its jurisdiction to determine administrative matters. If no other court retains "primary jurisdiction" over a trust, then the Court of Chancery can exercise its jurisdiction.

Judicial Modification of Trusts

The same law that controls a trust's administration will govern whether the Chancery Court can modify or reform the trust, whether all interested parties consented to the jurisdiction of the Court of Chancery or not. But for Delaware law to apply to reformation or modification, a Delaware trustee must administer the trust prior to filing a consent petition with the Court of Chancery.

If The Relief Sought May Be Fulfilled Under the Trust's Terms, the Court Will Not Issue Advisory Opinions

The Court of Chancery will no longer enter Orders blessing conditional appointments and resignations of trustees (Delaware and foreign) when the trust instrument requires no court's involvement to facilitate changes in trustee—eliminating this formerly "routine" prayer for relief. The Supreme Court affirmed the Chancery Court's holding such Orders are impermissible advisory opinions. This shift will likely have the reciprocal effect of increasing the reliance of Delaware's Non-Judicial Settlement Statute (12 Del. C. §3338) when a trust is to be moved to Delaware and modified (e.g. modifying a trust into a directed trust). View the Supreme Court opinions here, here and here.

Many compelling reasons exist for trust beneficiaries and trustees to move trusts to Delaware. Polsinelli's team of experienced legacy planning and trust attorneys, on-site in a local Delaware office, can assist in moving a trust to that state so it can avail itself to Delaware's advantages, including: (i) favorable trust administration and tax laws; (ii) the renowned Court of Chancery's exclusive jurisdiction over trust matters; (iii) creditor protection; (iv) the ability to create perpetual trusts (Dynasty Trusts); and (v) statutory authority for trust decanting and mergers, virtual representation, and non-judicial settlement agreements.

For More Information

For more information on the contents of this e-Alert, please contact:


About Financial and Fiduciary Litigation

The Financial and Fiduciary Litigation practice delivers common sense advocacy in the most highly-regulated and complex areas of the law. Whether in Chancery Court in Delaware, federal or state courts throughout the United States, or before regulatory agencies, exceedingly knowledgeable trial lawyers work closely with the firm's corporate finance transactional attorneys to provide seamless representation of our clients. [More...]

 
 

  

     

  

 
 

  

     

  

 

             
 

Atlanta  Chattanooga  Chicago  Dallas  Denver  Edwardsville  Jefferson City  Kansas City  Los Angeles  New York
Overland Park  Phoenix  St. Joseph  St. Louis  Springfield  Topeka  Washington, D.C.  Wilmington  
polsinelli.com

 
 

  

     

  

 
 

  

ABOUT POLSINELLI

real challenges. real answers.SM  
Polsinelli is a first generation law firm serving corporations, institutions, entrepreneurs and individuals nationally. Our attorneys successfully build enduring client relationships by providing practical legal counsel infused with business insight, and with a passion for understanding how to assist General Counsel and CEOs achieve their objectives. Polsinelli is ranked 18th in number of U.S. partners* and has more than 700 attorneys in 18 offices. Polsinelli was profiled in the June 2013 issue of The American Lawyer as the fastest-growing law firm in America over a five-year period. The firm focuses on healthcare, financial services, real estate, life sciences and technology, energy and business litigation, and has depth of experience in 100 service areas and 70 industries. The firm can be found online at www.polsinelli.com. Polsinelli PC. In California, Polsinelli LLP.

*Law360, March 2014

  

 
 

  

     

  

 
 

To update your email preferences, please contact Kim Auther at KAuther@polsinelli.com. To opt out of these communications, click the unsubscribe link below.

Polsinelli provides this material for informational purposes only. The material provided herein is general and is not intended to be legal advice. The choice of a lawyer is an important decision and should not be based solely upon advertisements.

Copyright © 2014 Polsinelli PC.

 
             
Connect with us on LinkedIn. Connection with us on Twitter. Connect with us on Facebook.